Epson Perfection V600 Photo Scanner

      Photo Review 8.5
      -/
      leadpic_V600_Left-Open

      In summary

       A capable, easy to use flatbed scanner with the ability to digitise prints, negatives and slides.The Epson Perfection V600 Photo slots in just above the V500 model but has a lower bit depth than the V700, which we reviewed in March 2006 and which remains as the premium model in Epson’s range. Designed for photo enthusiasts who want to scan prints, negatives and slides and has monochrome and colour originals, it handles originals up to A4 size and uses an LED light source to provide reasonably fast and colour-accurate scanning.  . . [more]

      Full review

       

      -
      leadpic_V600_Left-Open

      The Epson Perfection V600 Photo slots in just above the V500 model but has a lower bit depth than the V700, which we reviewed in March 2006 and which remains as the premium model in Epson’s range. Designed for photo enthusiasts who want to scan prints, negatives and slides and has monochrome and colour originals, it handles originals up to A4 size and uses an LED light source to provide reasonably fast and colour-accurate scanning.

      -
      Epson_V600_Left-Open-w-Film-Holder

      Epson’s Perfection V600 Photo scanner, shown with the supplied film holders. (Source: Epson.)

      The ReadyScan LED technology used for illumination in the V600 (and also the V500) is roughly twice as energy efficient as the light source in the V700. The V600 also features Epson’s Matrix on-chip CCD Micro Lens technology, which increases the amount of light entering the scanning head. Scanning times should be faster with this technology.

      Although the V600 can’t scan as many films as the V700 and it lacks some of its functions, all three models feature 6400 dpi optical resolution and all come with DIGITAL ICE Technologies provide advanced dust and scratch removal. Specifications of the three models are compared in the table below.

       

      V700

      V600

      V500

      Scanning head

      Matrix CCD with Micro Lens and Dual Lens System

      Matrix CCD (12 line with on chip micro lens)

      Light source

      White cold cathode fluorescent lamp, IR LED

      White LED, IR LED

      Optical resolution

      6400 x 9600 dpi

      D-max

      4.0

      3.4

      Bit depth

      Max. 16-bit grayscale; 48-bit colour

      Film handling:

      35mm strips
      35mm slides
      120/220 film
      4×5 inch

       

      24 frames
      12 frames
       2 frames;
       2 frames

      12 frames
      4 frames

      1 frame (up to 6 x 22 cm)
      not compatible

      Scanning times:
      A4 at 300 dpi
      35mm film
      35mm slide

      12 seconds
      44 sec at 2400 dpi
      47 sec at 2400 dpi

       

      6 seconds
      62 sec at 3200 dpi
      51 sec at 3200 dpi

       

      15 seconds
      63 sec at 3200 dpi
      55 sec at 3200 dpi

      Power consumption:
      Operating
      Sleep mode

      32 Watts
      4 Watts

       

      16.5 Watts
      1.6 Watts

       

      16 Watts
      4 Watts

      Interfaces

      USB 2.0; IEEE1394 Firewire

      USB 2.0/USB 1.1

      Dimensions (wxdxh)

      308 x 503 x 152.5 mm

      280 x 485 x 118 mm

      272 x 475 x 113 mm

      Weight

      6.6 kg

      Approx. 4.1 kg

      Approx. 4 kg

      RRP

      $949

      $549

      $449

       

       

       

       

       

      The software bundles are subtly different for each model, although all come with Epson Scan and Epson Creativity Suite plus ABBYY Finereader Sprint 6 (Win) / Sprint 5 (Mac) OCR software. Adobe Photoshop Elements 6.0 is bundled with the V700 and V500, while the more recently-released V600 gets Photoshop Elements 7.0 (Windows) and 6.0 (Mac). The V700 also gains the advantage of the sophisticated scanning application, SilverFast SE6, while the V600 gets Epson Event Manager, which enables users to assign any of the scanner buttons to open a program to which the scan can be directed.

      The V600 Photo is distinguished from the cheaper V500 model by lower power consumption in the Sleep mode. Otherwise, their specifications are similar. Both boast a 3.4 D-max optical density and both have a built-in Transparency Unit that enables users to scan two six-frame film strips, four mounted 35mm slides or a medium-format film strip up to 22 cm long.

      Setting Up
      The V600 comes in a large box with foam packaging that is split to make it easy to lift out the scanner. Compared with the V700, it’s surprisingly light and quite a bit smaller (particularly in height), and generally solidly built, although not up to the standard of the V700. With a footprint measuring 280 x 485 mm it occupies a fair bit of desk space but, overall, it looks quite smart.

      Once you’ve removed all the packaging tape (which secures anything that might move during transit), and unlocked the sliding security lock on the rear panel, you can plug the V600 into the mains power, switch it on (via a switch, low on the right side) and connect it to your computer via the supplied (and quite long) USB cable.

      The computer should recognise it as a new device and demand that you install the software. Software installation, which covered the applications listed above, is straightforward and takes several minutes. The software also installs a TWAIN data source in the Windows Imaging software on our computer, which meant that if we had Photoshop or Photoshop Elements open, the scan was sent directly to the editor.

      Four buttons on the front panel provide quick access to frequently-used functions, which are managed by the Epson Event Manager. The default settings are (from left): PDF, e-mail, copy and start. The PDF button lets you scan multiple originals and save them as a single PDF document.

      -
      V600_Button-Close-up

      The front panel buttons on the V600. (Source: Epson.)

      The e-mail button lets you scan a photo and attach the image file to an e-mail message. Pressing the copy button sends the scan directly to the default printer that’s connected to your computer, while pressing the start button opens the Epson Scan window, allowing you to select a scanning mode. These buttons are of little use for scanning photos so you’d be better off simply opening Epson Scan on your computer and going directly to the scanning modes (see below).

      Two LEDs are located left of the PDF button, the top one shining green when the power is on and flashing when the scanner goes into power saving mode. The lower one is an error indicator that flashes orange when an error is detected. Below the buttons is a long, thin blue status light that flashes when the scanner is initialising or scanning.

      A wide finger recess lets you raise the lid easily to reveal the scanbed and document table. The transparency unit is located in the lid, under a slide-out document mat, which is used when prints and documents are scanned.

      The lid has two locking positions, at 45 degrees and 90 degrees, that prevent it from dropping while you’re arranging originals on the document table. It can also be lifted about three centimetres to accommodate books and allow small, three-dimensional objects (such as jewellery) to be ‘photographed’.

      -
      V600_Left-Open-Brownie

      The V600 with the lid locked at the 45 degree position, showing the transparency unit and medium format film holder in place. (Source: Epson.)

      Prints and document are placed face down on the document table for scanning, with the top corner lined up against the top right corner of the document table. When you want to scan film, you must first slide out the document mat to allow the transparency lamp in the lid to be used.

      The transparency scanning slot is wide enough to accommodate two 35mm film strips, each with six frames. The V600 comes with two film holders; one for 35mm film strips and mounted slides and another for 120/220 film. Each holder has locator tabs that fit into one of three marked positions around the document table.

      -
      Scanbed-w-film

      The V600 document table with the 35mm film holder in position. (Source: Epson.)

      The A tab on the 35mm holder is used for 35mm filmstrips (also identified by a large white A on the holder. You rotate the holder through 180 degrees and connect the C tab for scanning mounted slides. The B tab is used for medium format film. While filmstrips are held in the holder with a covering frame, mounted slides are simply dropped into position after the holder has been installed.

      Scanning Modes
      When you’re scanning through Epson Scan, four scanning modes are supported: Full Auto, Office, Home and Professional. The Full Auto mode is designed for quick scanning and novice users and only provides correction like dust removal and colour restoration. It’s also the only image-scanning mode that doesn’t support previews.

      -
      Epson-Scan-Full-Auto

      The Full Auto mode in Epson Scan provides no scanning adjustments and only basic correction settings via the Customise button.
      The Home Mode is designed to let you adjust brightness and colour and optimise text or line art scanning – although these adjustments sometimes become inaccessible for no apparent reason. You can preview the image by clicking on the Preview button in the user interface. This pre-scans and displays the image(s) on the document table.

      -
      Epson-Scan-Home

      The Home mode requires you to set the Document Type and Image Type and select the ‘Destination’ for the scan (which will dictate resolution). It also provides several one-click adjustments.

      You can re-size the preview window with click -and-drag controls and it will display changes made by applying colour restoration. If you flip back to the Thumbnail display, the preview image is lost (a warning is displayed before you commit to it).

      The Office Mode is for scanning text documents, including multiple documents of the same size. This mode usually requires an automatic document feeder to be fitted. The Professional Mode, which also supports previews, provides a full range of adjustments and allows you to scan to a specific output ‘target’ size, such as A4. This is the mode serious photographers will choose.

      -
      Epson-Scan-Professional-mode

      The Professional mode provides a long scroll-down menu that gives access to all of the adjustments supported.

      Like the Perfection V700 Photo, the V600 comes with a lot of built-in technologies for removing blemishes and fixing faded colours. The driver includes dust removal and colour restoration in all scanning modes and these are the only corrections available in the Full Auto mode.

      The Home mode adds adjustments for de-screening (for copying pictures in books and magazines), backlight correction and DIGITAL ICE Technology, the latter providing more advanced dust and scratch removal – at the expense of longer scanning times. Brightness adjustment is also available via a dedicated tab.

      The Professional mode brings in a set of buttons that access an auto exposure setting plus histogram, tone correction, brightness, contrast and colour balance sliders and a colour palette with a graphical interface for adjusting mid-tone levels. Additional buttons for unsharp masking and grain reduction are also provided and these – along with the backlight correction and dust removal controls – are adjustable.

      -
      Pro-adjustments

      Adjustment windows in the Professional mode.
      There’s also a densitometer that lets you view each colour channel as you make adjustments when images are displayed in the preview window. The scanner also features PRINT Image Matching II technology. You can customise how certain Epson Scan settings behave by clicking the Configuration button and changing settings in the window that appears.

      The Configuration sub-menu contains four pages: Preview, Colour, Film Size and Other. On the Preview page you can adjust the densitometer and eyedropper sampling areas and thumbnail cropping as well as setting the preview to show image rotation and engaging auto photo orientation.

      The Colour page lets you set colour management parameters, display gamma and auto exposure values. The Film Size page covers the various sizes of 120/220 films. On the Other page you find a check box for implementing document skew correction and another titled ‘Show Texture’ which lets you preview how originals on textured paper will scan. The Reset All button is also found here.

      Scanning Performance
      Epson claims the V600 is capable of scanning times as short as six seconds – but that’s only for documents. Photos take somewhat longer, with scanning times depending on the size of the original and, in the Professional mode, the bit depth and resolution you set.

      When scanning snapshot prints, we found that, although you can fit four prints on the document table, if any of them touches another, the Auto Area Segmentation function (which is supposed to be able to separate them) sees them as combined and both snapshots are scanned as one image file. Scanning snapshots three at a time lets you separate them.
      The review unit took approximately 12 seconds to ‘warm up’ ready to begin scanning. Preview times were between 11 and 14 seconds, regardless of the size or type of original we scanned. The table below shows the times taken for a series of scans using different scanning modes, resolution settings and output target sizes and file formats. No additional processing (dust removal, colour restoration, etc.) was applied for these scans unless indicated.

      Original

      Resolution (dpi)

      Bit depth

      Scan Mode

      Scan Time

      File Size

      6 x 4-inch snapshot

      300

      n.a.

      Auto

      14 sec

      5.72MB TIFF

      3 snapshots

      300

      n.a.

      Home

      26 sec.

      ~250 KB each JPEG

      A4 colour print

      300

      n.a.

      Auto

      14 sec.

      23.8MB TIFF

      2 strips of 4 35mm colour negatives

      300 for 6×4 inch print

      n.a.

      Home

      450 sec.

      ~300 KB each JPEG

      6 unmounted 35mm trannies for A4 print

      300

      n.a.

      Home

      350 sec.

      ~500KB each JPEG

      2400

      24

      Pro.

      410 sec.

      ~19.7MB each TIFF

      4x 35mm mounted slides

      600 for A3 print

      48

      Pro.

      440 sec.

      ~400MB each TIFF

      1x 35mm slide same size

      12,800

      48

      Pro.

      380 sec.

      1.02GB TIFF

      1x 35mm slide with colour restoration *

      300

      48

      Pro.

      132sec.

      99.5MB TIFF

      1x 35mm slide with DIGITAL ICE *

      300

      24

      Pro.

      255 sec.

      49.8MB JPEG

      * for A3 print Target Size

      Preview scans display with a cropping frame indicated by a dotted line showing the area of the original that will be scanned. You can’t adjust this frame when scanning batches of originals and, if you have pre-set a target size, the frame can only be moved up and down.

      If you enlarge the preview to make adjustments before scanning, you must go back to the Thumbnail view before you can initiate the scan via the Scan button in the user interface. We couldn’t find anything in the user manual that tells you about this and spent quite a while trying to re-activate the scan button before finally discovering the solution.
      If you close the preview before scanning, you lose all the adjustments you’ve made – along with some other settings you have selected. The default Target Size setting for all scanning modes is Original, which means the scan will have the same dimensions as the original image.

      However, an odd thing occurred when we scanned batches of reversal (positive) film; only the first frame in the set was scanned at the resolution we specified. The rest were scanned at the same size as the original – although using the specified file format. The scanner also kept re-setting the target size to Original whenever we worked on an image preview so we had to make sure to check this setting before committing to a scan. Both these quirks were really annoying.
      The Progress window shows the Time remaining for each scan. In most cases it was a rough approximation and somewhat less than the actual time taken.

      High resolution scans produce very large files, particularly if output in TIFF format. You need a fast connection to transfer that data from the scanner to your computer. The V600 comes with a Hi-Speed USB 2.0 interface, so your computer needs the same interface (or faster) to support its data transmission speeds.

      Conclusion
      For scanning prints and documents, the V600 proved to be a reasonably competent performer, which is probably why it was voted as winner of the Best Photo Scanner category in the 2010 TIPA Awards. It also worked well with B&W negatives. On the basis of our experience, however, we can state that it’s not up to the performance of the V700 for scanning film, particularly transparencies.

      In addition, the Epson Scan interface is one of the most frustrating we’ve worked with on a scanner. While it’s simple to use if you stick with the Full Auto and home modes and make minimal adjustments to your scans, enthusiast photographers looking to ‘tweak’ image parameters before scanning can expect frustrations at almost every step.

      Another issue concerns the lack of support for ICC profiling in Epson Scan, which means you’re forced to rely on the built-in profiles. These, we have found, may not provide optimal output colours.

      The 3.4 D-max is also too small to cover the majority of slides. You need a minimum D-max of 4.0 to scan the full density range, particularly with shots taken in bright sunlight.

      Some overseas reviewers who have reported on the V600 claim it will work with other scanning applications. The V700 is supplied with one of the best of these: SilverFast Scanner Software (albeit in SE format), which can also be used with the V600 (and V500). You can download an evaluation copy from http://www.silverfast.com/scanner-software/ or purchase the SE version for 49 Euros (roughly $68). An alternative is Hamrick’s VueScan, which is available for US$39.95 from http://www.hamrick.com/.
      Buy this scanner if:
      – You want a competent, relatively fast scanner for digitising prints and B&W negatives.
      – You would like to be able to fine-tune images before committing to a scan.
      Don’t buy this scanner if:
      – You require the highest quality when scanning colour film originals.
      – You want a scanner to fit into a colour-managed workflow.
      – You are not prepared to invest in additional scanning software.

       

      Specifications

       

      -
      leadpic_V600_Left-Open

      Type: Flatbed A4 colour image scanner
      Scanning head: Matrix CCD (12 line with on-chip micro lens)
      Light source: White LED, IR LED
      Platen size: 216 x 297mm
      Film handling: 35mm strip film x 12 frames, 35mm slides x 4 frames, 6cm x 22cm medium format (120/220) x 1 frame
      Optical resolution: 6400dpi x 9600dpi
      Output resolution: 50 to 6400dpi (in 1dpi steps), 9600 dpi, 12,800dpi
      Bit depth: Max. 48-bit
      Scanning speeds: A4 at 300 dpi – 6 seconds; 35mm slides at 3200 dpi – 51 seconds; 35mm negatives at 3200 dpi – 62 seconds
      Dust and scratch Reduction: DIGITAL ICE for (Film and Print), Dust Removal Software for film and reflective/photo
      Interface: USB2.0 Hi-speed
      Power consumption: Approx. 16.5W (Operation); Approx. 1.6W (Sleep Mode); Energy Star rated
      Bundled software: Epson Scan 3.8, Epson Event Manager, Adobe Photoshop Elements 7 (for Windows)/ Adobe Photoshop Elements 6 (for Mac), ABBYY FineReader Sprint Plus 6 (for Windows)/ ABBYY FineReader Sprint Plus 5 (for Mac)
      Dimensions (wxdxh): 280 x 485 x 118 mm
      Weight: Approx. 4.1 kg

       

      Retailers

       

      CamBuy

       

      www.cambuy.com.au
      Digital cameras, lenses and accessories with 100% genuine Australian manufacturer’s warranties.
      Ph: (02) 9029 2219

      Camera House

       

      -
      CH_Logo120

      www.camerahouse.com.au
      Ph: 133 686
      The largest speciality photographic retail chain in Australia.

      Camera Pro

       

      www.camerapro.net.au
      CameraPro Pty Ltd
      Suite 607, 180 Queen St, Brisbane 4000
      Tel: 07 3333 2900
      Australian owned and run company based in Brisbane.

      Camerasdirect

       

      -
      CamerasDirect133

      www.camerasdirect.com.au
      Retailer of digital camera equipment and more.
      Secure online shopping and delivery across Australia.
      Ph: 1300 727 056

      Camerastore.com.au

       Camerastore.com.au
      Ph: 1800 155 067

      Camera-Warehouse

       

      -
      camera-warehouse120

      www.camera-warehouse.com.au
      Comprehensive range of digital cameras and accessories online (www.camera-warehouse.com.au) and an online print service (www.royalexpress.com.au).

      Digital Camera Warehouse

       

      www.digitalcamerawarehouse.com.au
      174 Canterbury Road 367 High Street
      Canterbury Northcote
      NSW 2193 VIC 3070
      Ph: 1300 365 220

      Electronics Warehouse

       

      www.electronicswarehouse.com.au
      1300 801 885
      Australian retailer of Vapex rechargeable batteries offering factory direct prices and fast, free shipping Australia wide.

      Greg Smith’s Photo Accessories

       

      www.dvdreamtime.com.au
      1800 50 80 82
      Big range of photographic accessories, Australia-wide shipping.

      Paxtons

       

      www.paxtons.com.au
      285 George St
      Sydney NSW 2000
      Ph: (02) 9299 2999

      Photographic Equipment & Supplies – Retail & Repairs. Click here for list of stores.

      Ted’s Cameras

       

      -
      Teds-Logo120

      www.teds.com.au

      1800 186 895
      Big range of cameras and photographic products with stores in most states and online.

      Rating

       

      RRP: $549

      Rating (out of 10):

      • Build: 8.5
      • Features: 8.0
      • Bundled software: 7.5
      • Scanning speed: 8.5
      • OVERALL: 8.5

      Buy